Self-Defense Handguns — Factors to Consider + Two Top Choices
Main photo from NRAILA.org. The NRA supports Second Amendment rights.
Article by AccurateShooter.com Editor-in-Chief
In the last month, a half-dozen acquaintences have asked me about getting a handgun for self-defense at home and while traveling. What is notable is that all of these persons have never owned a handgun before. Moreover, two of the six are pretty staunch liberals who, prior to 2020, thought the Second Amendment was a “historical anachronism” that should be repealed. With the widespread riots and “defund the police” activism, that has all changed. These six people now realize that there are real threats in current society and they may find themselves in a situation where armed self-defense is the only option.
Try Before You Buy — Find a Gun with Good Reliability, Controls, and Ergonomics
These six persons asked for recommendations on handguns. I explained that there was no one “best gun” for every person. I also stressed the importance of training, and of trying various handguns to compare ergonomics, weight, balance, sight arrangement, controls, and trigger pull.
Folks, ergonomics and grip shape DO make a difference. I used to give pistol instruction at a local club. I provided four 9x19mm pistols: Beretta 92, HK USP, SIG P226, and Glock 19. Two-thirds of the students shot best with the SIG P226, and only 10% shot best with the Glock 19. The majority of the students kept “pulling shots” with the Glock, even with a lot of practice. Not so with the SIG P226. I attribute that to lower center of gravity and more ergonomic grip shape/angle.
Caliber Choice — Factors to Consider
We are not going into the long caliber debate today. I have owned semi-auto pistols in .380 ACP, 9x19mm Parabellum, .40 SW, .45 ACP. Each cartridge has its pros and cons. But for a first-time gun owner, looking for a self-defense round, I will recommend the 9mm. It will have noticeably less muzzle flip than the .40 SW, but still carries much more energy than a .380 ACP. I love the .45 ACP for target shooting, but it is more expensive for practice, and there are fewer pistol options. For revolvers, the .357 Magnum is a great defense round, but some of the smaller carry pistols are limited to .38 Special.
Semi-Auto 9mm Carry Gun Recommendation: S&W M&P9 Shield EZ
I have considered a wide range of 9mm carry pistols from Glock, Ruger, SIG Sauer, Smith & Wesson, Taurus, and Walther. There are many very good pistols out there. But what I recommended to my acquaintances was the new Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield EZ 9mm. This gun features a back-strap grip safety and is offered with or without thumb safety. There is also a M&P9 EZ model with built-in Red Laser.
Here are the key reasons I recommended the M&P9 EZ 9mm pistol:
1. Good Accuracy and Balance
2. Integral Grip Safety and optional Thumb Safety
3. Good Ergonomics: 18-degree grip angle for natural point of aim
4. Reasonable 4.5-lb Trigger Pull (some other pistols are 7+ pounds*)
5. Easy-to-Rack Slide
6. Take-Down does NOT require trigger pull (unlike Glock)
7. Availability of built-in laser or accessory rail-mount lights/lasers
8. Good Price: $479.00 base MSRP with $399.99 street price
9. Outstanding Smith & Wesson reliability, warranty, and customer service
This detailed, authoritative M&P9 EZ video review also covers the M&P .380 Shield EZ:
Small Deep Concealment Carry Gun Recommendation — S&W Model 638
I am a big fan of revolvers. I have probably put more rounds through my S&W Model 617 .22 LR revolver than all my other handguns combined. Revolvers are accurate, solidly built, and the shorter-barrel models conceal easily. In addition, revolvers are inherently simple — they can be put into action without racking a slide or dealing with mag latches and the like. I’ve actually seen trainees drop magazines on the ground when they were drawing pistols from holsters — they hit the mag release by accident. If this can happen in a class, it can happen in a threat situation.
S&W Model 638 Airweight from Guns.com.
For concealed carry, I recommend the Smith & Wesson Model 638 revolver. IMPORTANT — the Model 638 has a hammer so it can be shot single-action OR double-action. Having the single-action option is great when a slower, more precisely-aimed shot is needed. Unique among S&W revolvers, the 638’s hammer is shielded — this way the hammer will not snag when the gun is carried in purse or pocket.
As for accuracy, you will be surprised with the Model 638 with good self-defense ammo. Despite the short site radius, the little 1.875″-barreled Model 638 will easily outshoot most self-loading .380 ACPs. With my 638 Airweight, slow-fire, I can put all five rounds inside 2″ at 20 feet with ease.
* Some folks may criticize this S&W Shield 9mm EZ because it lacks a heavy 7-9 pound trigger pull. The thinking is that a heavy DA pull is better for novices. We understand the argument. However, in the real world we found that novices shot much worse with very heavy trigger pulls, even after much training. We believe a 4.5-lb pull is moderate and will actually allow better accuracy for the average shooter. A typical Glock pull-weight is about 5.5-6 pounds.
Similar Posts:
- Carry Gun Bargains — Five Pistols under $250.00
- Carry Pistol Comparison: SIG P365, S&W Shield, Glock 43
- 9mm Carry Pistol Comparison: Glock, Sig Sauer, Smith & Wesson
- Smith & Wesson 9mm Shield Pistol $199.99 with Factory Rebate
- Last Day Today for Smith & Wesson Wheelgun Rebate
Share the post "Self-Defense Handguns — Factors to Consider + Two Top Choices"
Tags: .38 Special, 9mm Pistol, 9mm Shield, Airweight revolver, Carry Pistol, Grip Safety, M&P9 Shield, Model 638, Pistol Recommendations, S&W Shield, Smith Wesson 638
My wife was one who recently made the same choice to “carry” , and after several months of extensive training by me , she went though a CCW class , and took the test , passing with a 98% on her written . After test shooting a box-car load of virtually every small frame pistol , she chose the GLOCK 43 as her personal carry pistol . Because she was properly trained to begin with , on a GLOCK 19 . She cleans and maintains her own pistol , and has passed every inspection by me afterward . Trained correctly , it doesn’t matter what pistol is in a beginners hands . If it does matter , maybe they shouldn’t be carrying at all . A potential danger to themselves , and others around them .
Editor: I have owned four different Glocks over the years and shot thousands of rounds through them: G17, G19, G23, and G34. They were all very reliable, and the G34L was exceptionally accurate. Based on what I’ve seen, however, the vast majority of regular shooters (not IPSC masters) shoot better with more ergonomic non-Glock pistols. I also prefer pistols with safeties.
I’m going to risk offending the powers that be , by asking , “Why the constant and continual inference that Glocks aren’t SAFE pistols that don’t have safeties . They don’t have a MANUAL safety , but they do have built-in safety mechanism in the trigger . Slanted information is just as bad as Mis-information . Bias is still bias !
EDITOR: There is a blade in the trigger on Glocks, and various other pistols. This, arguably, will prevent accidental discharge if the weapon is dropped or part of the trigger snags on exit from a holster. But the weapon cannot be put “on safe” — it can always be fired if you pull the trigger. And I have seen ADs in classes with Glocks and other guns that were carried with a round in the chamber. And yes, you can certainly have an accident with a safety-equipped gun too if it is not engaged properly. Bottom line however, if the positive safety can perform a function, there is no reason not to have it. The S&W M&P9 EZ is available with or without a thumb safety. The grip safety is nice because no separate action is required to activate a lever. Just grip the gun normally.
It’s great that this article explains that the shape of the grip plays a part in choosing the right gun for you. Maybe it would help for gun owners to get adhesive grips. This could help them carry their firearm more securely and safely.